Information and Resources for the Final Project
Read these articles about giving a good (math) talk: Article 1, Article 2, Article 3, Article 4. Visit this web page, this blog, and watch this webinar.
First choose your partners (you should work in groups of size 2 or 3) and a topic in history of mathematics in the Islamic World. The topic should include significant amount of mathematics. The final project has 2 components: presentation and paper. For the presentation part, you have 3 options: talk (power point presentation), poster, or digital storytelling. If you choose the story telling option, please check out some resources here.
Important Note: Please do not choose a topic without looking at resources first. Therefore, get the books (order them from Ohio link if necessary) well in advance of the first deadline.
Timeline and Deadlines for the Project
Proposal: Let me know, in writing, what topic you choose by Mon Oct 21 (week 8). You should submit, in writing, your choice of the topic, the group members, what you plan to cover in the presentation and the paper, the format of the public presentation (one of the 3 options), and an annotated bibliography. If you choose a topic that we covered (or will cover) in class, make sure you go above and beyond what we did in class and explain how. Explain what you will focus on for the public presentation vs final paper. You need to come up with a good title for the public presentation part. 2-3 pages would be sufficient for the proposal (one proposal per group).
Outline: Next, you submit an outline of your paper by Wed, Nov 6 (week 10). If your presentation is a digital storytelling, then you submit your narrative separately at this time. The purpose of the outline is to help you specify and clarify what you will cover in the paper, and to help you make progress towards the final products (paper and presentation). The outline should be 3-5 pages and include more details and specifics than the proposal. It should also include a bibliography. Spacing should be 1 or 1.5. The more you include, the better (onlty one paper per group is to be submitted).
Draft Paper: This should be a complete draft of your paper that includes all major parts and most details. The deadline is Wed, Nov 20 (week 12). You are highly encouraged to receive feedback for your paper from the writing center. If your presentation is a digital storytelling, then you must submit a complete draft of your video as well. It is also required that you receive feedback from CIP prior to submission of your compelete draft. You need to document that you received feedback from CIP.
Rehersal Presentations: You will present your project to the class (talks should be 15-20 minutes, and digital stories 3-5 minutes) to receive feedback from your peers and the professor on Mon and Wed of Week 13 just before the main public event at NICC on Friday of the same week. All groups must be prepared to present on Monday Dec 2. The public event at NICC will take place on Friday Dec 6, at 8 pm. We will leave campus at 5:15 pm.
Final Paper: The final paper is due at the official final exam date for this course which is 6:30 pm, Wed December 18. There is no fixed length for the final paper but keep in mind that it is a subtantial paper and must include non-trivial amount of mathematical material. It should be no less than 10 pages (1 or 1.5 spaced). One paper per group. Please do citations properly and avoid plagiarism. Your paper will be checked for potential plagisarism issues.
A good paper has the following characteristics:
- Has substantial content
- Involves significant amount of mathematics
- Goes well beyond what we did in class (if there is common material)
- Well written: organization, transitions between sections and paragraphs, grammar and spelling
- Has appropriate quotations, citations, and references. Listing references at the end is not enough, you need to cite them in the paper.
- Avoids plagiarism.
- Includes relevant figures and refers to them within the text. Showing figures in presentation is not a substitute for the written paper.
Here are some possible topics to give you an idea and get you started but this is not an exhaustive list. You may choose another topic with the approval of the instructor.
- Check out the links given on the main course web page including the documentaries.
- Lives and works of Islamic mathematicians that are available in Complete Dictionary of Scientific Biography (available as an electronic source through Kenyon). Take a look at this page and this too..
- These articles have many pointers and sources: Forgotten Brilliance, Math in Muslim Heritage, Contributions of Muslims to Math
- Many possible ideas and sources at this page, and more generally here.
- Many suitable topics in the book "The development of Arabic mathematics: between arithmetic and algebra", Roshdi Rashed (translated by A. F. W. Armstrong), Kluwer, 1994. (available at course reserve)
- Combinatorics in Islamic Mathematics. Look at the relevant chapters in
- Chapter 7 of Berggren
- The Mathematics of Egypt, Mesopotamia, China, India and Islam, A Sourcebook, Victor J. Katz editor, Princeton U Press, 2007
- A History of Mathematics: An Introduction, 2nd ed, Victor J. Katz, Addison-Wesley 1998
- The development of Arabic mathematics: between arithmetic and algebra, Roshdi Rashed (translated by A. F. W. Armstrong), Kluwer, 1994
- Algebra and Linguistics: Combinatorial Analysis in Arabic Science, in "The development of Arabic mathematics: between arithmetic and algebra"
- Number Theory in Islamic Mathematics. Chapter 7 of Berggren and "The development of Arabic mathematics: between arithmetic and algebra"
- Mathematics in Islamic Art and Architecture. You can start by reading these 3 articles: Article1 Article 2 Article 3. Also look at this page and see the books below.
- Islamic Geometric Patterns (notice that there are several books listed at the bottom of the page)
- Geometry Needed by Craftsmen
- Geometry of Artisans,The Mathematics of Egypt, Mesopotamia, China, India and Islam, A Sourcebook, Victor J. Katz editor, Princeton U Press, 2007
- Algebra in the Islamic World: Beginning and Developments (see the books below)
- Ideas of Calculus in Islam and India. Look at these two articles: Paper1, Paper2
- Cryptanalysis of al-Kindi. A starting point is here.
- Alhazen's Problem. Can start by looking at these two articles: Article1, Article 2. Berggren's 2nd ed contains a section on Alhazen's problem (section 3.7)
- Ibn al-Haytham and Wilson's Theorem, in "the development of Arabic mathematics: between arithmetic and algebra", Roshdi Rashed (translated by A. F. W. Armstrong), Kluwer, 1994
- Ibn al-Haytham and Perfect Numbers, in "the development of Arabic mathematics: between arithmetic and algebra", Roshdi Rashed (translated by A. F. W. Armstrong), Kluwer, 1994
- Ibn al-Haytam's treatise on the volume of a sphere.
- Ibn al-Haytham and Ideas of Calculus in his measurement of a paraboloid. Check out this paper, and the two books: The Mathematics of Egypt, Mesopotamia, China, India and Islam, A Sourcebook, Victor J. Katz editor, Princeton U Press, 2007; Calculus and Its Origins, by D. Perkins, MAA, 2012.
- Construction of a Perfect Compass and other geometrical instruments, The Mathematics of Egypt, Mesopotamia, China, India and Islam, A Sourcebook, Victor J. Katz editor, Princeton U Press, 2007
- Numerical Equations, in "the development of Arabic mathematics: between arithmetic and algebra"
- Numerical Analysis and extraction of nth roots, our tetxbook and "the development of Arabic mathematics: between arithmetic and algebra"
- Thabit b. Qurra (his life and contributions to mathematics), A History of algebra : from al-Khwarizmi to Emmy Noether, B.L. van der Waerden
- Spherical Geometry and Trigonometry in Islam (Chapter 6 in our textbook)
- V. Robert's paper on connections between Copernicus and Ibn al-Shatir.
- Astronomy and Astrology in the Medieval Islamic World.
- Observatory in Islam.
- Muslim daily prayers and mathematics required to determine them, In synchrony with the heavens : studies in astronomical timekeeping and instrumentation in medieval Islamic civilization, by David A. King, 2004.
- The role of religion in the development of mathematical sciences in the Islamic Civilization.
- Islamic Engineering, Mechanics and Technology. See the book "Islamic Science and Engineering" and the encylopedia under the folder "Resources" in the P drive.
- Other possible topics from the Encyclopedia of Science and Technology in Islam, available in the P drive.
- Look at the Exercises and Bibliography at the end of each chapter of the textbook to get more ideas for possible project topics.
Some Useful Books and Other Sources for the Project (can get ideas for possible projects from these sources too)
- Complete Dictionary of Scientific Biography (available as an electronic source through Kenyon),: Charles Scribner's Sons, 2008. 27 vols (searching for names can be tricky!)
- An online Bibliography of the Mathematical Sciences in Medieval Islamic World by Jeffrey Oaks.
- The Mathematics of Egypt, Mesopotamia, China, India and Islam, A Sourcebook, Victor J. Katz editor, Princeton U Press, 2007 (in course reserve)
- The development of arabic mathematics: between arithmetic and algebra, R. Rashed, Kluwer 1994 (in course reserve)
- A History of Mathematics: An Introduction, 2nd ed, Victor J. Katz, Addison-Wesley 1998
- A History of algebra : from al-Khwarizmi to Emmy Noether, B.L. van der Waerden
- Introduction to the history of science, George Sarton, 1975
- Arabic Mathematical Sciences, R. Lorch, Variorum 1995
- An Episodic History of Mathematics, Steven G. Krants, MAA publication 2010
- Calculus and Its Origins, by D. Perkins, MAA publication, 2012.
- 1001 Inventions: Muslim Heritage in Our World, Salim T S Al-Hassani, 2nd ed, 2007, Foundation for Science Technology and Civilisation (UK)
- Studies in the Islamic Exact Sciences, E.S. Kennedy, colleagues, and former students, American University of Beirut, 1983
- In synchrony with the heavens : studies in astronomical timekeeping and instrumentation in medieval Islamic civilization, by David A. King,Leiden ; Boston : Brill, 2004.
- Astronomy and Astrology in the Medieval Islamic World, by E. S. Kennedy, Variorum, 1998 (available at Kenyon library)
- The Observatory in Islam and its Place in the General History of Observatory, by A. Sayili, Turkish Historical Society, 1960.
- A critical edition of Ibn al-Haytham's On the shape of the eclipse : the first experimental study of the camera obscura, by D. Raynaud, Springer, 2016.
- Ibn al-haytham and analytical mathematics, by R. Rashed, (trans. by S. Glynn and R. Wareham), Routledge, Taylor & Francis Group, 2013.
- Islamic Science and Engineering, by Donald R. Hill, Edinburgh U. Press, 1993.
- Encyclopedia of Science and Technology in Islam, pdf available in the P drive.
- Al-Khwarizmi : the beginnings of algebra, edited, with translation and commentary, by Roshdi Rashed, SAQI, 2009.
- The Algebra of Mohammed ben Musa (transl. by F. Rosen), London: 1831. Another edition Honolulu, HI : University Press of the Pacific, 2003
- The Algebra of Abu Kamil: Kitab fi al-Jabr wa'l-muqabala, University of Wisconsin Press, 1966. Also check out this article.
- The Algebra of Omar Khayyam, by Daoud S. Kasir, Teachers College Columbia University, 1931
- Algebra wa Al-Muqabala of Omar Khayyam, translated by Roshdi Khalil, Garnet Publishing, 2008.
- Pathfinders: The Golden Age of Arabic Science, J. Al-Khalili, Allen Lane, 2010
- Arabic mathematical sciences : instruments, texts, transmission, R. Lorch, Variorum, 1996
- Science in medieval Islam : an illustrated introduction, Howard R. Turner, U of Texas Press, 1999.
- Islamic Geometric Patterns, E. Broug, Thames& Hudson, 2008.
- Islamic Geometric Design, E. Broug, Thames& Hudson, 2013.
- Islamic art and geometric design [kit]; activities for learning, the Metropolitan Museum of Art,New York, N.Y. : Metropolitan Museum of Art, c2004
- Islamic design : a genius for geometry, D. Sutton, Walker & Co, 2007
- Islamic art and architecture : the system of geometric design, Issam El-Said, Reading, UK, 1993.
- al-Biruni-Instruction in the Elements of the Art of Astrology
- A collection of resources related to Al-Kashi.
- The Muslim Heritage web site
- A History of Islamic Science
- Bibliography of Mathematics in Medieval Islamic Civilization
- Bibliography by Topic of the Mathematical Sciences in Medieval Islamic World
- Mathematics in Medieval Islam
- A Digital Library
More resources on Islamic art here.