From the September 29, 2003 issue of New York Magazine Feature
Israel's Christian Soldiers
Citing Scripture, Evangelical Christians have taken up
the cause of preserving Israel with a passion -- no matter how many liberal
Jews find their unlikely devotion unsettling.
Israeli cabinet minister Binyamin Elon
was in New York several weeks ago to wrap up a hectic swing through the
Southeast that included stops in Memphis, Atlanta, and several other cities.
It was a muggy afternoon, and Elon, a soft-spoken bear of a man who has
a full beard, looked a little weary as he filled a chair at the Israeli
Consulate on Second Avenue.
A potent political figure back home, Elon wears two hats (in addition
to his knitted kippa): He is Israel's Tourism minister and the
head of Moledet, one of the small right-wing parties that help keep Ariel
Sharon in power. On his visit here, he was working both portfolios pretty
hard, often with the same people. In private meetings with political activists,
as well as in speeches before religious groups, Elon pushed the importance
of visiting Israel now.
Since the second Palestinian intifada began three years ago,
the number of visitors to Israel has plummeted from more than 3 million
a year to barely 1 million. In the days just before the war in Iraq, Elon
was actually giving out gas masks to visitors. "I was," he says sardonically,
"probably the world's only minister of tourism who was able to personally
meet each of his country's tourists."
Solidarity with the Holy Land is the current sales strategy. Elon hopes
that, at least among the believers, religious faith will outweigh fear:
"For obvious reasons, we are not trying to compete with the Virgin Islands
as a family-vacation spot."
When he slipped on his Moledet hat, Elon went from pitching tourism
to practicing politics. His agenda was simple: to instigate and solidify
opposition to the Bush road map.
An Orthodox rabbi who lives in the West Bank, Elon favors a two-state
solution to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. But in his version, Israel
keeps the West Bank and Gaza. The Palestinians get to become citizens
of Jordan, which, he says, is already a de facto Palestinian state. He
argues with alacrity that the creation of a Palestinian state in the West
Bank and Gaza -- which he says would never be economically or geographically
viable anyway -- would actually be a three-state solution.
Wherever Elon went, he was warmly received. Which may not be surprising,
since he was clearly preaching to the choir. What is surprising, however,
is that it was the Christian choir he was preaching to, not the Jewish
one. During his five-day trip, Elon spent virtually none of his time among
Jews.
Instead, he spoke at the Mid-America Baptist Theological Seminary in
Memphis and lunched there with a group of pastors. He met with Roberta
Combs, president of the Christian Coalition. He spent time with Mike Evans,
founder of the Jerusalem Prayer Team and author of Beyond Iraq: The
Next Move, a book that depicts Islam as evil and finds biblical harbingers
of the end of time in the current global crisis.
"The Evangelicals may now be seen as even more
important allies than American Jews."
He talked to former presidential candidate Gary Bauer, now head of
American Values, a conservative Christian group. And he beamed with pride
in snapshots taken when Ed McAteer, one of the founders of the Moral Majority,
brought him to see a billboard in downtown Memphis that loudly displayed
a passage from Genesis: AND THE LORD SAID TO JACOB . . . "UNTO THY OFFSPRING
WILL I GIVE THIS LAND."
At every stop and at every meeting, Elon was signaling the importance
that the Jewish community, and especially Israeli politicians on the right,
places on its relationship with America's swelling Evangelical Christian
community. And while this alliance between the Evangelicals and the Jews
is not new, it has suddenly taken on a sense of urgency and an intensity
that haven't been seen before.
AIPAC, the powerful Israeli lobby in Washington, chose Gary Bauer to
speak at its most recent annual dinner. The Zionist Organization of America
honored televangelist and onetime presidential candidate Pat Robertson
with its State of Israel Friendship Award.
Rabbi Yechiel Eckstein, who founded the International Fellowship of
Christians and Jews twenty years ago, was named the third-most-important
Jew in America by The Forward. The reason? He spent years as a
kind of outcast among his peers for his efforts to foster better relations
between Jews and Evangelicals; now the Jewish community has begun to see
things his way.
And when House Majority Leader Tom DeLay, the conservative, born-again
former exterminator from Sugar Land, Texas, addresses the Knesset, as
he did several weeks ago, and says, "I stand before you today, in solidarity,
as an Israeli of the heart," you know something's going on.
Indeed, the world -- and not just that part of it between the Mediterranean
and the Jordan River -- is a very different place from what it was in 1980,
when Israeli prime minister Menachem Begin outraged much of the Jewish
community by presenting the Jabotinsky Centennial medal to the Reverend
Jerry Falwell for his work on behalf of Israel.
In the two decades that followed, the relationship between American
Jews and Evangelicals was at best lukewarm. Though the Evangelicals periodically
offered support, their overtures to the Jewish community were generally
met with skepticism. Many Jews believed that what the Christians really
wanted was to convert them. Or to persuade all of them to move to Israel
as part of some devious plan to hasten the coming of the end of days as
laid out in the New Testament.
But much of that queasy reluctance has been overcome, or at least pushed
aside, as Israel's situation has worsened. As the violence gets more
horrific and more relentless, and the overall outlook more bleak, Israel
seems to have fewer and fewer friends. Support from the Evangelicals,
however, hasn't wavered. In fact, the more beleaguered Israel seems
to be, the more passionate its Christian friends have become. "I have
always said," Jerry Falwell told me recently, "that America's Bible
Belt is Israel's safety belt."
Three critical developments have deepened the alliance. One is the
stunning rise in anti-Semitism around the world and the feelings of insecurity
it has stirred among Jews. The second is 9/11, and the third is George
W. Bush. The president is a born-again, Scripture-loving Christian who
sees the world in stark, almost biblical, terms ("You're either with
us or you're with the terrorists"). He is also surrounded by a coterie
of advisers who similarly see the war on terrorism and the current conflict
as a clash of civilizations, a battle between the East and the West.
"Conservatives generally and Christian conservatives specifically
see our foreign policy in moral terms," says Bauer. "And they see
Israel as the good guy, a democracy, a nation much like ours. And they
see Israel's opponents as a collection of thugs, dictators, and self-appointed
kings."
Bauer believes Israel and America are fighting essentially the same
battle, the battle against Islamic terrorism. "The only solution is
to completely defeat the enemy and then figure out what a just peace is."
But for the Christians, this blossoming relationship is about much
more than politics. Evangelical Christians' support for a safe and secure
Israel with borders stretching perhaps from the Mediterranean to the Jordan
River, and their oft-expressed love for the Jewish people ("the apple
of God's eye"), are rooted in deeply held religious beliefs.
They believe God promised Israel to the Jews. It is the Holy Land.
The land where Jesus lived and died. The land where Jesus will return
to save the world. "When you add this belief that Israel is their spiritual
homeland," says Rabbi Eckstein, "to their belief that we are in a
global battle against terrorism, it is a powerful mix."
It is the kind of support rarely offered to Jews -- especially these
days. "Let's be honest," says Rabbi A. James Rudin, who was director
of inter-religious affairs during his more than 30 years with the American
Jewish Committee. "It's hard to ignore their support even, as my father
used to say, if they're doing the right thing for the wrong reasons."
Further adding to their appeal as suitors, Evangelicals have considerable
political muscle. A recent Gallup poll reported that 41 percent of voting-age
Americans are born-again or Evangelical Christians. Most, of course, are
active, committed Republicans, and they have been the catalyst for the
shift in political power from the Northeast and Midwest to the South and
Southwest.
"Israelis have known for a long time that Evangelicals are about
the strongest supporters Israel has," says Dr. Richard Land, president
of the Southern Baptist Convention's Ethics and Religious Liberty Commission.
"It's been a shock to Jews in America, but I think it is beginning
to catch on now."
It is not a shock to Eckstein, who for years was the lone Jewish voice
in the wilderness working to build bridges between the two groups. "More
and more Jews see the Evangelical community as a strategic ally for Israel,"
he says. "In fact, the Evangelicals may now be seen as even more important
allies than the American Jewish community itself. But are Jews willing
to have a beer with them? I'm not so sure."
At first glance, this alliance looks
like a very bizarre mixed marriage. Jews are mainly urban, educated, liberal
Democrats. They also tend to be secular. "We take refuge in our ethnicity
rather than our spirituality," says Rabbi Gerald Meister, an adviser
to the Israeli Ministry of Foreign Affairs on Christian relations. Jews
are extremely uncomfortable with God talk, even if it's other Jews doing
the talking.
Evangelicals, on the other hand, are unabashed in expressing their
love for Jesus and their devotion to the Gospel. They tend to be similarly
blunt about their social agenda. On nearly every key domestic issue -- abortion,
gay rights, school prayer, school vouchers, gun control, separation of
church and state, affirmative action -- they hold a different position
from that of most Jews.
There are, to be sure, exceptions. On the Jewish side, there's a
small but growing group of Republicans that includes Paul Wolfowitz, Richard
Perle, Bill Kristol, and the rest of the neocons. In the Christian camp,
it's important to note that Bill Clinton, Al Gore, Richard Gephardt,
and Jimmy Carter are all Southern Baptists.
This yawning gap on so many critical issues, however, continues to
keep many Jews from welcoming Christian support. Rabbi David Saperstein,
director of the Religious Action Center of Reform Judaism in Washington,
believes it is dangerous for Jews to compromise their beliefs. "If the
American Jewish community buys the support of the religious right by its
acquiescence on domestic policies, that would damage our religious freedom
and our tradition of pluralism and tolerance," he says. "It will be
a disaster for America and for Jews."
Of course, this match between Evangelicals and Jews may be no less
odd than the coming-together of leftists, human-rights activists, atheists,
and assorted liberals with Islamic fundamentalists. Though they are ideologically
light-years apart on virtually every issue, they demonstrate together
because they share a hatred of George W. Bush and the conviction that
Israel is an imperialist oppressor.
"America is a nation of millions who believe like me that Jerusalem,
Bethlehem, Hebron, and Jericho are part of the biblical heartland,"
Elon says. "We can argue about the Messiah, when he will come, how he
will come, but we agree about the basics. And this is more important than
anything else."
The alliance gives Jews a lot more clout when they campaign on behalf
of Israel. It is not Jews alone beseeching Congress and the White House
on Middle East policy. When Evangelicals speak out, too, it doesn't
look as though American foreign policy is being disproportionately shaped
by a small minority with a powerful lobby and an insider's knowledge
of the system.
"It's not President Bush being blackmailed or pressured by the
lobbyists of a minority," Elon says. "It's good for American Jews
to understand that they have friends in the White House and on Capitol
Hill who will honor the Bible and protect Israel because of their own
beliefs."
American Jewish support for Israel is also affected by the reality
on the ground in the Middle East. When Israel appears to be too aggressive
or too forceful or to be mistreating the Palestinians, liberal American
Jews get uncomfortable. Though few would admit it publicly, they are at
times embarrassed about Israel among their liberal Christian friends who
sympathize with the long-suffering Palestinians and see Israel as some
sort of reckless Goliath. The settlements, the fence, the depictions of
soldiers shooting at kids, Ariel Sharon's belligerence: All of it causes
great angst among secular, liberal Jews.
"We are not supposed to be victors," says Rabbi Gerald Meister.
"We are not supposed to survive well."
Binyamin Elon is more brutally blunt: "I'm not going back to Auschwitz
to regain anybody's sympathy."
The Evangelicals, however, suffer no doubts about the rightness of
the cause. "It would be a terrible mistake to try to create a Palestinian
state between Israel and Jordan in the West Bank," Gary Bauer says without
a hint of self-consciousness. He believes the land belongs to Israel and
economic incentives should be used to "encourage" West Bank Palestinians
to go somewhere else.
He is equally unambiguous on the subject of Palestinian suffering:
"The suffering of the Palestinian people is due to the actions of their
leaders and to the behavior of the other Arab and Muslim states."
Dr. John Hagee is pastor and impresario
of the Cornerstone Church in San Antonio, Texas, a sprawling, colonnaded,
5,000-seat facility that is so active it has to hold Sunday-morning services
in two sessions. With as many as a dozen ministers on staff, its own television
programming, and a robust business selling books and videotapes, Cornerstone
is typical of the thriving mega-churches throughout the South and Southwest.
Hagee is a passionate supporter of Israel with a long history of involvement
in the cause. He recalls sitting in the kitchen of the family home in
Channelview, Texas, as a boy, listening to the radio one day in 1948 when
the news broke that the U.S. had recognized the state of Israel. Hagee
has a vivid memory of his father, a pastor and a Bible scholar, looking
across the table at him. "He was a man of few words," Hagee remembers,
"and he said to me, "This is the most important biblical event of
the twentieth century.' We both cried with joy, and to this day I believe
that to be exactly true. Every major prophet in the Old Testament said
that the state of Israel would be reborn. Isaiah 66:8 says Israel will
be born in a day, and it happened just like the prophets said it would."
Every fall, Cornerstone hosts "A Night to Honor Israel." At last
year's event, the church was packed, the program was beamed around the
world by satellite, and the keynote speaker was Tom DeLay. There were
also video appearances by Ariel Sharon and Benjamin Netanyahu.
At one point, enormous American and Israeli flags were unfurled side
by side from the ceiling, and the church choir (and many in the congregation)
sang "The Star Spangled Banner" and "Hatikvah." Hagee talked about
the importance of Israel for twenty minutes, and before the evening was
over, he presented a check for $1.5 million to the president of United
Jewish Communities.
This kind of extraordinary Christian support for Israel still comes
as something of a shock to most East and West Coast Jews (not to mention
most East and West Coast mainline Protestants and Catholics).
When talking about the founding of Israel and its early days as a nation,
Hagee sounds as awestruck and full of wonder as the World War II generation
of American Jews once did. "The Jewish people came from 66 nations of
the world, speaking every conceivable language," he says in sonorous,
gravelly, preacherlike tones. "And they started studying Hebrew, and
miraculously the Hebrew language was reborn. And a nation that started
out draining the swamps and fighting mosquitoes became a powerful, forceful
nation in the Middle East. It is an enormous miracle. Israel is the only
nation ever created by a sovereign act of God."
Though Hagee may be a little more flamboyant in his presentation than
the average pastor, the emotional strength of his feeling about Israel
is not unique. He is representative of Christian Evangelicals as a group,
whose view of the world, and their place in it, is totally based on theology.
The bedrock of their beliefs is what they call the "inerrancy of
the Bible" -- their unflinching certainty that everything in the Bible,
as the word of God, is literally true. Their fervent support for Israel
and their unexpectedly solicitous feelings for Jews flow from several
key passages in the Bible. Foremost among them is God's covenant with
Abraham, made in Chapter 12 of the Book of Genesis, which promises the
land of Israel to the Jews forever. God, the Evangelicals will tell you,
does not break his promises.
And in one simple passage in Genesis 12:3, the Evangelicals' unshakable
bond with Jews is sealed: God says to Abraham as he is forming this new
nation to be called the Jewish people: "I will bless those who bless
you, and I will curse those who curse you."
"It is God's foreign-policy statement," says Hagee.
Dr. Richard Land of the Southern Baptist Convention is more explicit.
"If we want God to continue to bless America, then we need to bless
the Jews," Land says. He offers the twentieth-century fates of Germany,
Poland, and Russia as evidence that the divine promise made in Genesis
is being kept. "And look at what's happened in the Arab countries,"
Land says. "Who in America would rather live in any Arab country?"
The most controversial, and the most
often talked-about, piece of the Evangelicals' Jewish puzzle is the
end-of-days scenario. For skeptical Jews, this is the eschatological equivalent
of a gotcha, a piece of evidence that lifts the curtain and reveals what's
really going on.
Though specifics are a little sketchy, there is a generally accepted
version of events leading up to Judgment Day. First, and this is key,
Jews will return to Israel. A wicked world leader -- the Antichrist -- will
assume power by deceiving everyone into believing he will bring peace.
Soon after, the final battle, the Apocalypse, Armageddon, will be fought.
At its conclusion, Jesus will descend from Heaven. He will come down
the Mount of Olives on the east side of Jerusalem, through the Golden
Gate, and into the city. (Just in case, Muslims bricked over the Golden
Gate when they controlled the Old City.) There will then be a thousand-year
reign of peace on Earth.
Jews who are aware of the end-of-days story line note that when these
events are set in motion, they will theoretically result in the eradication
of the Jewish people. Aside from untold numbers of Jews who will die in
the final battle, those who do not convert when Christ returns will die
anyway -- as will all nonbelievers.
"Jews are at best divided on accepting the short-term
benefits of being players -- or victims -- in someone else's script."
Evangelicals believe in the end of days as much as they believe in
everything else in the Bible. Tim LaHaye and Jerry B. Jenkins have written
a collection of novels called the "Left Behind" series that use the
Bible's apocalyptic events as their core. They have sold more than 40
million books.
The American Jewish Committee's James Rudin has led many Christian
tour groups in Israel, and one of the places they always want to see is
Har Megiddo in the Galilee. Har Megiddo is where the word Armageddon
comes from.
"It usually takes about two hours," he says. "They don't just
walk the area; they pace it, marking it off and measuring it. This is
where Gog and Magog will fight in the final cataclysm. They take this
very seriously. It is central to their beliefs and the Second Coming of
Christ."
Jews are at best divided on accepting the short-term benefits of being
players -- or victims -- in someone else's script. Rabbi David Saperstein
in Washington, D.C., sees potentially grave consequences: If Evangelicals
resist strategies designed to achieve Middle East peace and instead, backed
by Jews, promote extreme policies (like expelling all Palestinians from
the West Bank) in order to bring about some huge conflagration, the results
could be disastrous.
Every Evangelical I spoke to, however, was emphatic that their position
on the End Days has been misrepresented. John Hagee, for example, told
me he does believe we are coming to a point in time the Bible calls the
last days. But he argues that there is a big difference between believing
something is going to happen and believing you can somehow make it happen.
"My grandfather was a pastor," he says, "and some of his congregants
became so convinced the End Days were approaching, they didn't plant
their crops and they starved to death. God has an exact timetable, and
he is going to do what he wants to do when he wants to do it."
Evangelicals are no less candid on the other major problem most Jews
have in accepting their outreach at face value: conversion. Richard Land
says he knows how Jews feel about this issue but there is little he can
do about it: "We have a mandate from Jesus Christ to share the Gospel
with all who will listen. And unlike some mainline Protestants, we're
not embarrassed about it. What Jews need to understand is, we don't
believe in coercion, and we're not treating them any differently than
we treat our grandparents and aunts and uncles and friends. We believe
the Gospel is for everyone."
The very concept, however, is anathema to many Jews. It resonates with
anti-Semitism and echoes many of the worst crimes committed against Jews
throughout history.
No one is more familiar with the sensitivity of the conversion issue
than Yechiel Eckstein. He will not work with any group that specifically
targets Jews for conversion. His organization, the International Fellowship
of Christians and Jews, has 300,000 Christian donors. He gets 2,000 letters
and checks a day, and last year he gave $20 million to Jewish charities.
He also donated 45,000 winter coats to Israeli grade-school kids who
live below the poverty line. Five Orthodox towns refused the clothing,
however, because the money came from Christians. Several Orthodox Israeli
rabbis attacked Eckstein, who is also Orthodox, as a Christian missionary.
"Is it possible that all this love and all this money is simply a
way to get in the front door and then bring Jesus in through the back
door?" Eckstein says. "I suppose. But after twenty years of close
relations with the Evangelicals, I strongly doubt it."
Eckstein offers what he believes is proof of the purity of Christian
motives. There is a woman in Del City, Oklahoma, who donates 10 percent
of her monthly Social Security checks to help an elderly Jew who lives
in Tashkent, Uzbekistan, buy clothes and heating oil.
"That woman in Uzbekistan is not going anywhere," Eckstein says,
"either literally or figuratively. She's not emigrating to Israel,
and she's not converting to Christianity. The donation is a genuine
act of love, comfort, and solidarity."
After years of refusing to recognize the validity of Eckstein's work,
American Jewish leaders are now betting he is right. They acknowledge
it's a risk, but one they believe, given the political power of the
Evangelicals, is clearly worth taking.
And so, while the sight of Israelis welcoming Tom DeLay like an old
friend, or Gary Bauer addressing a major American Jewish organization's
annual dinner, might look like strange, desperate acts to some, it is
actually calculated, practical politics.
"American Jews may still feel more comfortable with their liberal
Protestant and Catholic friends," says Eckstein. "But there's a
growing recognition that push has come to shove, and we're now finding
out who our real friends are."
Copyright © 2002, New York Metro, Llc. |